Rossi Blog Reader
This website tracks recent postings to Andrea Rossi's
Journal of Nuclear Physics,
sorting the entries with priority to Rossi's answers, which appear under each question.
• Need more context? We also have Rossi's entire blog on a single page.
• You can also keep an eye on Defkalion's latest postings to their forums.
• Website comments to the Webmaster (who has no contact or connection with Rossi).
• Email to Andrea Rossi - Journal Of Nuclear Physics
Andrea Rossi:
Congratulations on your historic vindication! The third party report was very impressive confirmation.
I am wondering if you could now tell us what transmutations you think are responsible for most of the energy generated by the Ecat?
Regards; HRG.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
I along with some thirty friends, to whom I have regularly reported over the past two long years, the developments of the extraordinary adventure of your E-Cat, want to thank you for your hard work and want to share with you our great satisfaction and joy for the publication of the third-party report with the confirmation of all your claims – con buona pace di tutti i soloni accademici (I can’t translate it).
Your exceptional scientific insight and your stubborn determination have made available to the present desperate human community the most unthinkable and providential “wonder of all time”: a clean, unlimited and low cost energy; a tool capable, if properly used, to project our world into a new global renaissance.
Thank you Mr. Rossi for ever.
Best Wishes,
Bruno & Friends
Dear Mr. Rossi, I’m astonished by the results of the report, as the whole world should be.
Not because of lack of trust about your previous results, but because I believe that from now on even the most rigid detractor will need to view under a different light your work.
I wish you the business success you deserve, but I also expect to see a much stronger involvement of the scientific community into LERN research. It’s time to divert a substantial amount of funds (maybe from the useless ITER) to better understand the physical principles beyond your invention.
I’ve been working in the energy field for almost 20 years, I expect to work for the next 20 around the new landscape that you are shaping.
Mr. Rossi
I was wondering if you might be able to talk about some of the specific results in the third party test.
The third party reviewers commented that the second test used your more advanced activation system. This system did not generate as high temperatures and had a lower COP (2.9). Has this been consistent with your experience?
Thank you for taking the time to answer my question
Brian
Dear Andrea,
You designed your reactor so that it is not very easy to access the chamber that houses the secret powders.
So essentially you put a constraint on your reactor design such that it is difficult to tamper with.
Question:
Do you think that if secrecy was not an issue and was not a constraint in the design of your reactor, then the design could be improved and made more effective and efficient, even by a little bit?
Best regards,
Patrick
Dear Patrick Ellul:
No, not at all.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Hi A.R.
This is on the first page on oilprice.com
http://oilprice.com/Latest-Energy-News/World-News/Rossi-Vindicated-E-Cat-Tested-by-Third-Party-Investigation.html.
Dear Andrea,
It’s great to see so many positive responses here. You must be very gratified.
Here’s something interesting from the Prometeon website: http://prometeon.it/news.php
Dr. Christos Stremmenos reports that he built his own reactor and brought it to your lab where it was charged with your nickel powder — and similar positive results to your own were measured.
Could you explain to readers more about this interesting development?
Best wishes,
Frank Acland
GRAZIE. GRAZIE DI TUTTO.
GRAZIE PER L’ITALIA CHE HAI ANCORA ONORATO.
GRAZIE PER I PIU’ POVERI DEL MONDO CHE POTRANNO AVERE UN FUTURO MIGLIORE.
CHE DIO (ECCO UN ALTRO DA RINGRAZIARE) CONTINUI AD AIUTARTI ED AD AIUTARCI
Dear Gian:
Thanks to you, yes we will do all to make this tech useful for the issues you listed.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr. Rossi,
My congratulations to you for such a monumental contribution to nuclear physics, and its safe and practical utility. I regard your achievement as equal to that of heavier than air flight. Perhaps you have captured nuclear supersymmetry with the E-cat. Which, if it is, is perhaps the deepest symmetry in Nature.
Kind regards
Peter Fimmel
Dear Peter Fimmel:
Thank you, but I do not think our energies are such to make the job you said…even if NUclear is so UNclear…
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Mr Rossi,
Do you think you will able to improve on the results the tester obtained with higher COP with stable temps.
Thank you
Dear Manuel Cilia:
Yes.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dott.Rossi,
my best compliments for the confirmations you got on the cats !
You knew it, but when something is widely recognized by the community and honorable persons it has a different taste.
All the best, Gherardo
PS: thanks to you, I’m going to get an overdue pizza from a friend
Dear Gherardo:
Thank you; about what you say, today an important recognizement came from Forbes:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/markgibbs/2013/05/20/finally-indipendent-testing-of-rossis-e-cat-cold-fusion-device-maybe-the-world-will-change-after-all/
Thanks ,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
This is a VERY special day. Thank you for the Upright spririt that guided you, allies againt all odds !! Keep it up that way & all the best,
Michael S
Dear Michael Schneider:
Thanks to you.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
Reading the thirdy party report, I find a strict analogy between e-cat and the ballistic fly of a mass:
- if you use too much energy the mass leave our planet (the reactor fuse)
- if you use too little energy the mass have a parabolic fly (self sustain mode)
- if you use the right energy the mass enter stationary orbit (infinite ssm)!
Now, learn from satellite launching missions: don’t rely only on ballistic fly, have a continue control on input energy!
Dear Silvio Caggia:
Thank you!
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Congratulations Snr Rossi! I read the report today with joy in my heart. Can I ask you Sir, What were your hopes when you agreed to allow the tests? And who do you see as the audience of the report?
Dear Blanco 69:
I was sure that whatever the result, it surely had to be honest and really indipendent: none of the Professors are competitors, none made patents in competition with ours, all are totally indipendent from us under the economical point of view as well as economically indipendent from any competitor of us; they have no connections with our competitors, as we could certify. Their work has been hard, very conservative, professional and totally indipendent from us as well as our competitors and from big corporations or Government Entities that want to compete with us and made patents trying to copy us. This is why we trusted them to the point that we gave them our device leaving them totally free in a room deserted by us, at their complete disposal, where they did what they wanted without any limitation put by us. The sole limitation we put has been the impossibility to open the reactor and look at the internal structure of the E-Cat.
About the audience: I am receiving many beautiful comments, to each of which I want to answer with my personal thanks. Thank you!
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Professors, Doctors, Engineers, and all the people who contributed to this historical event:
Congratulations on your excellent work !
One order of magnitude of proof ! 1000 %
It may be of some importance to mention that in both cases of the tests, the E-Cat HT and E-cat HT2 were in the state of “idling”, and thereby already performing that impressive.
Andrea,
If these devices get integrated in a sytem that is capable of controlled heat extraction, by means of cooling-fins with measured temperatures, IR reflection screens and flows of different densities, heat capacities and temperatures of coolants, the performance (Power and COP) might increase one order of magnitude again ?
I compare it with the performances of a modern car. When the engine is idling, it consumes infinite litres per 100km. When I drive my car in the first gear, and let the engine idle again, rolling slowly at some 5km/h, the consumption is about 25 litres per 100km. This way, the engine produces about 150 Watts of mechanical energy. But at 90 km/h, and in top gear, the engine consumes no more than 5 litres/100 km, producing some 30 kilowatts. Most engines have an optimal working point with minimum grams of fuel consumed per effective kWh (mech) produced. The performance at idling does not tell a lot of the performance at the optimal point.
So there might be a very good chance that the E-cat HT(2) performs even better when under (regulated) load.
Another analogy with the car engine is that if you push the accelerator when the gears are in neutral, thus wihtout a load, the first thing that happens is that all the power is used to accelerate the engine to the speed where the valves touch the piston and everything breaks.
So without a “load”, the E-cat HT heats too fast and melts. It is not only a matter of reaching a high temperature, but also a matter of extracting enough heat on a controlled way. The tests were in idle-mode, so it was very important not to push the device to temperatures where a forced cooling is needed to avoid a runaway. A forced (emergency) cooling would have spoiled all the measurements. But the numbers of the reports indicate that COP is better at higher temperatures, and that there is some exponential relationship.
So, as an engineer, I am very interested to see what the so called “flange” of the E-cat HT2 fits on. The stove that fits the fire.
Andrea, every opinion can be considered a resonance in the brain.
Kind Regards,
Koen
Dear Koen Vandewalle:
thank you for your suggestion,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi, Just read the independent 3rd party report. Great news, never doubted the performance of the e-cat. You are obviously onto another important level. Keep up the good, all the very best Eric Ashworth.
Dear Eric Ashworth,
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr Renato Estri:
I agree.
Warmest Regards,
A.R.
Hi Andrea, remember … facts will speak for me!
The time has come.
Hot regards.
Dear captain:
OK,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Congratulazioni. Questo report mi ha davvero emozionato cosi come anche le tue splendide parole per Sergio Focardi. Continua cosi.
Dear Luca Salvarani:
Thank you, also for reminding Prof. Sergio Focardi: he has been revitalized by the Report.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
AWESOME! I have trusted your word from the day I first became aware of your work in 2010.
Perhaps now Champagne?
Congratulations!
Antenna
Dear Antenna:
Now more work: the Report is an encouragement to work more on all the uncomplete issues.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr Joseph Fine:
Thank you! Yes, now back to make a tremendous amount of work.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Thank you for allowing us to follow your progress these last 2 years! I hope the COP found by the testers was as good as you had hoped. I know you had reservations about doing the test, but I hope the results are to you and your partners satisfaction.
Howard Herrington
Dear Howard Herrington:
Yes, you are right,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr. Rossi,
The high quality of the third party, independent report was worth waiting for.
A very entertaining read as well as a scientifically informative report. Congratulations!
The six-month additional test that is planned for this year is good news, indeed.
I won’t hold my breath for the USA media to report these great test results.
It will probably take a Hot Cat with Siemens steam/electric turbine providing electricity to the entire city of Buffalo, New York for 5 years plus a 3-year DOE scientific study to get the attention of AP, Reuters, and the TV News Broadcasters.
You have made an amazing amount of progress in a very short time, Dr.Rossi.
You should ask your new boss for a bonus payment.
Wishing you continued great success.
Best Regards,
Daniel G. Zavela
Dear Daniel G. Zavela:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
Congratulations to you and Prof. Sergio Focardi on the release of the Third Party Report.
Many thanks to the Report Authors who performed all the tests, made the measurements and did the analysis.
Soon, this process will be known as a normal (not “anomalous”) form of heat energy production.
Maybe, you can even enjoy a vacation for a day or two!
But then, back to work!
Keep on keeping on!
Joseph Fine
Dear Andrea Rossi,
I would suggest to dedicate officially
this historic date 20th MAY 2013, that
will become a milestone day for the modern science,
in honor to the great Professor Sergio Focardi.
Renato Estri
Dear David Robertson:
Thank you very much: I saw the comment you made in Sweden, I agree.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dr Rossi,
Congratulations on the release of the third-party report.
Hopefully, the world will now know what you have always known.
All the best,
Joe
Dear Joe,
Thanks,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Rèmi Andrè:
Thank you.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea,
From all the team at MFMP, congratulations on the fruits of your hard work and dedication.
Bob Greenyer
Dear Bob Greenyer:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
I’ve posted my report about the 3rd party results, including links to other coverage on the topic. Includes the Ragone plot, by Alan Fletcher.
Exciting stuff.
VINDICATION! Third-Party E-Cat Test Results Show at Least 10x Gain – The debate about whether or not Andrea Rossi’s E-Cat technology really works are put to rest with a definitive, third-party test report having been released today stating that at the most conservative, the Hot-Cat technology showed at least a ten-fold increase in power over what could possibly have been ascribed to any presently-known chemical process. (PESN; May 20, 2013)
Tomorrow I will tell to all my pupils (the same that prayed for the success of the 28th of october 2011 test) that the report has been published and that there is now hope for mankind.
A very big thank you for your achievement !
Un grand merci de France !
Congratulations for the positive results! I have been following your progress for a couple of years and had confidence that you would come through for us.
Keep up the hard but important work as you progress with the design. We are all rooting for you and the world needs this technology very much.
Thanks again,
Dave
You Only Live Twice or so it seems,
One life for yourself and one for your dreams.
You drift through the years and life seems tame,
Till one Dream appears and eCat is its name.
And eCat is a stranger who’ll beckon you on,
Don’t think of the danger or the stranger is gone.
This eCat is for you, so pay the price.
Make one Dream comes true…
- In honour of Andrea Rossi and of the eCat 3rd Party Report, freely adapted from the Sinatra’s song.
Dear Nicola Cortesi:
He,he,he…thanks!
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
Congratulations for the independent test report, it’s a very big milestone. It was also nice to see (from the certification and public acceptance point of view) that they were not able to measure any radioactivity outside the reactor (i.e. that the radiation was not only small, but unmeasurably small, as I understood).
I see one curious detail about the melted reactor in November: they write that the reactor’s steel and ceramic parts melted at the described overheating event (at the end of Figs 1-2 caption on page 2). I find it curious because the melting point of most ceramic materials is higher than the melting point of nickel. Does it imply that the melting of the nickel does not always shut down the reaction immediately, but some temporary heat production may continue even in liquid metal phase? Or maybe their statement is not fully accurate, maybe the ceramic parts did not actually melt, but were only displaced and broken because of melting of the steel parts? Maybe you can shed light on this issue?
best regards, /pekka
Dear Pekka Janhunen:
To answer to your question I should disclose confidential information regarding the ceramic layers composition and their function. The statement is fully accurate.
Thank you for your kind attention,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Thank you for allowing my children a chance for a better world!
Thank You Rossi!
Dear Rafi Israel:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
Congratulations on such a favourable report!
Dear Matin Leonard:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Congratulation on the great news Mr. Rossi, many of us have always believed in you and the Ecat this is a great day for all humanity, Thank you and you Team for all the hard work you have done and will continue to do until we can all have a domestic Ecat. You deserve the Nobel Prize for this.
John
Dear John:
Thank you: you are right, we are a good Team, and in the Team I enclose our Readers, that always have sustained with their empathy our work.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea, and now?
What is next step?
Giuseppe
Dear Giuseppe:
Lavolale, lavolale!
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea, not only you deserve a Nobel prize for your discovery and hard work but the gratitude of the entire planet Earth for giving a beacon of hope to humanity in making the right and correct changes for a brighter future. A massive THANK YOU and I promise you that I am hoping to contribute on my part of spreading the news far and wide! Today is probably the best day of my life!!
Dear Christian Bistriceanu:
Thank you very much,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Ing. Rossi,
I have seen the third party report. Many, many congratulations! Surely the world must now wake up to the immense importance of your work.
I have for a long time watched your work with interest, as far as was possible, using only the internet. While I have tended to maintain a certain amount of scepticism, I have felt that LENR was probably real and that your work was genuine. I wish you the very best for the future and hope that the ECAT will bring you wealth and happiness. You deserve both.
Very best regards,
Stephen G. Haw
Dear Stephen G. Haw:
Thank you very much,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
You have made a believer of me today. Congratulations, Mr. Rossi!
Dear Glenn:
Welcome!
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Gent.mo Dott.Rossi,
se nel passato la ho “disturbata” per chiederle chiarimenti su dubbi e curiosità, oggi scrivo qui solo per condividere con lei e con i suoi collaboratori questa fantastica giornata! Auguri di cuore per questo primo, prestigioso riconoscimento
Il futuro sono sicuro le riserverà tanti nuovi sacrifici ma altrettante grandi scoperte e soddisfazioni! Incrociamo le dita
Ing. Benedetto Schiavone
Dear Ing. Benedetto Schiavone:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
grazie,
oggi é una bella giornata.
Buon lavoro.
Dear Pietro F.:
it is indeed,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dire GRAZIE è banale!
È forse meglio dire….buon lavoro!
È ora? Che succede? Chi promuoverà questa grande conferma?
Many specials thanks to Sergio Focardi and team of Leonardo C.
La tradizione dei Leonardo, Galileo, Volta, Marconi, Meuci, Fermi, Majorana
Si è così rigenerata!
Dear Gian Luca:
Thank you for having reminded to all of us the name of Prof. Sergio Focardi: he has teached to me many foundamental things, has helped me through all the safety issues, has always sustained our work also in the most difficult moments. The publication of this report has also given evidence that he was right when he believed in the LENR. His enormous Heritage of scientific knowledge, specifically in Physics and Mathematics ( I study every day on his book of Mathematic when I need to go rigurous), his capacity of organization ( he founded the Cesena Branch of the University Alma Mater of Bologna, when he was Dean of Science Faculties of the same University), his generosity in dispensing knowledge has made him a giant of the Italian Scientific world, and one of the most delighting things of my work is to contact him every day to learn something.
God bless you, my dear Prof. Sergio Focardi.
And again thank you, Gian Luca, for reminding us who he is.
Andrea Rossi
Dear Mr. Andrea Rossi
Congratulation on the great news and
great work you have done.
Best regards,
Pavel
Dear Pavel Vrbovski:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
A very unusual coincidence, in the historic day of ECAT and LENR….
http://www.affaritaliani.it/green/2000-km-con-un-litro200513.html
future looks green and pink !
Dear Andrea Rossi!
Congratulations for the successful third party report! Hope you can enjoy a few good drinks on your success. I tried to contact the editor at Spiegel Online who wrote an article on your research in 2011:
http://www.spiegel.de/wissenschaft/technik/kalte-kernfusion-herr-rossi-sucht-das-glueck-der-menschheit-a-801836.html
Hope they will make an update. Fingers crossed…
Best regards,
Julian
Mr. Rossi
I wanted to congratulate you on the third party report and the work you’ve done. While I have been following your work with great interest because of its tremendous potential, I was very skeptical. If I had been forced to bet, I probably would have bet on you being revealed as a fraud.
I am very pleased and excited to be wrong in my assessment. Good luck to you going forward.
Dear Andrea!
Great congratulations for the great report which I just finished reading. Clear concise and irrefutable.
I am still on the waiting list for the home-cat…
Best regards from Israel
Guy
Congratulations, Andrea Rossi!
I´ve been waiting for this moment and have just read the report.
It´s a historical day for mankind and för the enviroment.
Anders L
Hi “Sir” Andrea,
The next step is hopefully to stop the loosers high energy nuclear fusion projects (like ITER) and to focus the funds to the e-cat.
The after next step, hopefully will be, once you and your firms have been covered of gold, the I.P. will be donated to the mankind for a faster development.
Honoured to congratulate with you “Sir” Andrea Rossi.
Alessandro Coppi
Dear dott Rossi,
you have a lot of friends !!
Dear Mr Rossi,
I am very happy to hear about your progress and that the validation report finally have been published.
Keep up the good work!
/DB
… che dire?
GRAZIE!
Dear Fabio 82:
What to answer? Thanks to you!
Warm Regards,
A.R.
CONGRATULATIONS FOR THIS HUGE STEP THAT WE KNEW WAS COMING
Bernie
Dear Bernie Morrissey:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Congratulations on the report! It is a great day! Thank you for your work!
Dear Valery Tarasov:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr Renato Estri:
Thank you!
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr. Rossi,
Wonderful news!
Greatest Congratulations on the publication of the Third Party Report.
In years to come they will create a “Google Doodle” to mark this important day!
Martyn Aubrey
Dear Martyn Aubrey:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Da non pubblicare.
Caro Andrea, comprendo la sua correzione,
oggi e’il giorno per gioire non per l’acrimonia,
un abbraccio e continui a testa bassa,
il tempo stringe,
con affetto Maurizio.
Dear Maurizio:
Why not publish?
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
Congratulations: YOU ARE THE (ECAT) MAN!
Dear argon:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Congratulations ! On the 3rd party report!
Whats a moment to remember in history !
Regards John L
Dear John L:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Hans Joachim Mueller:
Thank you,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Congratulations!
Felize
Dear Felize:
Thank you!
Warm Regards,
A.R.